Monday, November 30, 2015

Post 58 -- Goals, not fully trivial.

I have a goal. It isn't a glorious one or even one that most people wish to attain. Thus far I have been successful in working my way to some of my goals, while others have been re-assessed and pushed to different priorities.

Workouts continue. As November 30, I am at 85% attendance rate at the gym (or doing a workout in general). Sacrifice and discipline. Some days I hate it; exhausted, beaten up, and unwilling to endure another session of sweat and discomfort. Thankfully, I appreciate a more eudaimonic lifestyle: small sacrifice now, by way of calories, sweat, and time, and crucial benefits later. When it comes to workouts, this is no different.

Back in March of 2013, there was an incident with a piano and myself. About 900 lbs of piano toppled my direction during the unload of it. The downward force, which I did not drop, extended my back while compressing it with enough force to blow out three discs. A recent re-aggravation made my belief about the matter only more apparent. Obesity--hell, even slightly overweight--is only going to turn my life in a ceaseless torment of back spasms, increased nerve pain, and would accelerate the pesky problem of arthritis in my post-surgical joint.

Humble-brag aside, I wanted to illustrate the power of discipline when it comes to attaining goals. My goal of being fit is not something that will persist once "achieved". I must pursue it--endlessly so. Stoically. At times, tirelessly, or at least by way of mental fortitude.

This concept and habit of mine has been utilized in other areas of my life. For now, rather than boring you, my dear reader, I want to put the lens on the another goal, the one vaguely alluded to at the start. I wish to join The Rationalists. It isn't something which can merely be applied for and accepted on mere principle. Quite the opposite: it appears one must have a consistent, high quality production of predominately YouTube videos.

This is a mountain, just not an impossible one. It can be climbed, but first I must have my footing. Do not take this as a letter of intent for the pursuit. Not at all--just me, looking into a mirror, stating what I want.

This has been an unedited rant. Come talk to me on Twitter: @nrokchi

Friday, November 20, 2015

Post 57 -- No platforming or the monopolizing of time?

Let us begin by discussing what the term no platforming means. In its most simplest of terms, to no platform a speaker is to prevent him from having access to a stage or audience, thus preventing him from sharing his views. Without the ability to share his views, those opinions will not be impressed upon the audience.

Immediately it becomes clear why this is done, but with two interpretations depending on one's level of cynicism. If one is naive, then the argument in favour of no platforming is to save supple minds from being warped by heinous ideas (e.g., Holocaust denialism); conversely, the cynic says the act of no platforming is to stifle open discussion of topics. Both approaches do not address the central driving force behind the act.

If there is limited time to speak then one would ideally maximize that time with the best possible information. Now, let me invoke Wilkinson's Law and frame this in the most common venue for no platforming: the college campus. The soft and pliable minds of young students cannot properly analyze and critique terrible, monstrous, or intolerant ideas, so it is an act of compassion to prevent the airing of them. Well now, what of the time which would have otherwise been spent on sharing these terrible, monstrous, or intolerant ideas? Why, let us put in place the ideas which are not terrible, monstrous, or intolerant!

Now, let us reframe this slightly but placing no value on the ideas and just labeling them as simply ideas. Rather than "terrible, monstrous, or intolerant ideas" we now have "ideas". So we have the denial of time to one set of ideas and instead the sharing of another. The rejection of the first set was a based on the weakness and frailty of the youthful minds. These moral arbiters have instead utilized the time to espouse safe and positive ideologies... on these same weak and frail minds.

It ought to be clear by now what I'm aiming at, but in the event that it isn't, let me take one final crack at this. Social justice warriors are willing to "save" the minds of young students (i.e., their peers) from hearing horrendous ideas out of fear that those ideas will take root in their uncritical minds and instead will preach social justice to the very same sponge-like minds. No platforming is not about preventing "bad ideas" from being shared, but about monopolizing the time to spread the already established dogma; to entrench the ideology of social justice so as to choke out any possibility of even critical analysis of any non-social justice related issue, just as a well-seeded lawn prevents the growth of weeds.

Control plays an important part of this process, but again, it is not solely about control of the platform. It is predominately about the control of minds who would otherwise hear the no platformed views. Supple minds must be fed a particular set of ideas in order for them to "expand" down the narrow tunnel of social justice. By stifling the free speech on campus through the cowardly act of no platforming, these activist students have created a small box for their minds to live in. Moreover, they are ever vigilant in expanding this encompassing and intellectually suffocating box around the minds of their fellow collegians, eventually turning them into equally fearful and righteous students.

A glaring example of no platforming is not with a him but with a her. Ms. Germaine Greer, one of the most prolific voices in second-wave feminism, was attempted to be no platformed by the Cardiff Student Union's women's officer Rachel Melhuish via the do-nothing-activist hub change.org. The talk did take place on 18 November as scheduled, despite the petition and the slacktavist ramblings of a one Payton Quinn, who wrote four articles on why the act of no platforming is good via Huffington Post UK.

For context, Ms. Quinn (Mr.? I know there has been a transition, but I am entirely unaware of what the starting point was as compared to what the end point is) spends the articles complaining about being misgendered (see above), noting how freedom of speech and expression is established law in the United Kingdom, wholly misunderstanding the difference between hate speech and individual opinions (which, mind you, do not advocate intolerance or violence in this particular case), and ultimately arguing that there should be no freedom of speech where her/his (really, this is not done maliciously, I am truly ignorant of Quinn's gender situation) feelings or opinions may be harmed.

In Quinn's most recent article on the matter, there is a fantastic example of how not understanding that no platforming is tantamount to the erosion of free speech, lamenting the jab of one attendee who said, "No, I believe in free speech" as she rebuked the flyers on offer. The flyers were selections of Greer's writings on transwomen. Quinn had purchased tickets, but chose not to attend, creating the perfect irony: the act of no platforming prevents all from hearing the views of Greer, stripping them of choice. By exercising choice, Quinn was not exposed to the views of Greer while allowing others to.

So comes the Fallout shelter problem: the entire community tells you it is dangerous to leave, as the world outside is dangerous. Instead, it is best to stay in the dark, tight, small shelter and listen to the administrator, for he knows best. The mere act of pondering to leave is met with derision and scorn. It is best not to upset the collective... and to listen and believe.

Find me on Twitter: @nrokchi

Wednesday, November 4, 2015

Post 56 -- Milo misunderstands net neutrality.

It shouldn't come as a shock to most that the fabulous Milo Yianopolous isn't perfect. While close, there are some strange quirks about the man that were uncovered in his conversation with Joe Rogan during The Powerful Joe Rogan Experience #702. A small example is the love for a monarch and people being "born and bred to rule".

Another stunning example of Milo's short comings--which contradicts his pro-consumer #GamerGate stance and conservative business values--is his disdain for net neutrality. At the basis of this is his misunderstanding of what net neutrality is attempting to do. I will provide a few examples though this to clarify for those who do not understand what the impact of net neutrality has on individuals and businesses.


Here is where it starts in JRE. 


"It's about the government regulating the internet," says Milo in his argument that net neutrality is inherently anti-free speech. He goes on to state, "it is about the government trying to intrude into the private relationship between a company and it's customer. Net neutrality is about the government trying to intrude into that relationship and dictating what kind of business arrangement you can come to with [your internet provider]."


In summary of Milo's points, net neutrality is a direct intrusion by way of government over reach into private contracts between two parties.


Milo continues to add some nonsense about the government attempting to interfere with ISPs having tiered services for their customers, a claim that is entirely bogus on its face.


Here is where Milo, and other anti-net neutrality advocates, need a small education on how business views net neutrality. This is not merely ramblings of someone who doesn't know better; I have information from a lead developer of one of the largest cloud companies in the world who has spoken with me about how his company would approach a world of net neutrality and the world without it.


Let's start with an example. Three men walk into McDonald's. One works for Radio Shack, one works for the city, and one is unemployed. They all wish to purchase a Big Mac. The man from Radio Shack pays $1.50. The man from the city pays $1.00. The unemployed man pays $2.00. Each of these men received the same service, had the same wait time, and received identical burgers in presentation and calories. Why did they have to pay different amounts? Well, that's because Radio Shack and the city have contracts with McDonald's which states what they get to pay for their Big Macs. The unemployed fellow has no such contact, so it forced to pay a higher rate for the same item.


Let's use those same three men again. This time, they are all purchasing a Big Mac and they all pay $1.50 for it. The man from Radio Shack gets the standard Big Mac. The man from the city gets a Big Mac with additional cheese and two additional burger patties. The unemployed man does not get cheese and only gets one burger patty. Again, because of the contracts between each company, the same named item is distributed at different levels for the same price.


But wait, there's more! This isn't just about the Big Mac contracts. This is also about the people providing the produce, condiments, buns, and beef. Each contract dictates how each individual contract receives a different quality product for each burger component. This is not an act of reducto ad absurdum; rather, this is illustrating the point with an example which most can imagine themselves being in.


To extrapolate this out into your personal contract with your ISP, consider the following: not only do you negotiate (or more likely just agree to what is being offered) on your internet speed (e.g., 15 Mbps upload/ 1 Mbps download), but your agreement would also contain hundreds of pages of what bandwidth is available between you and the internet sites which you might visit. So, even though you would be purchasing a, let's say, basic package (15/1), you would not get a smooth 15 Mbps download maximum from each site. Instead, you would see a list such as:

  • YouTube: 1.6 Mbps down, 0.5 Mbps up
  • Twitter: 0.5 Mbps down, 0.2 Mbps up
  • Reddit: 5 Mbps down,  0.01 Mbps up
  • Amazon: 1 Mbps down, 1 Mbps up
  • ... and so fourth.
Each company's rate would be determined through what each company pays for its data to be shared through the ISP and to each customer based on rates determined outside of the maximum upload rates. Expanding this out a bit more, this means that, for example, one particular ISP is vehemently anti-pornography--be it evangelicals or feminists--they could say those particular packets of information from any web hosting service which deals with hosting pornography are different from non-pornography packets and charge a rate so absurd that the cost to the consumer and host would be prohibitive. A Christian ISP could do the same to atheist content hosts. We have already established that search engines such as Google cannot write algorithms which hide or undervalue results from its competitors. Why should we allow ISPs to determine what each packet of information is worth simply based on the company or hosting service from whence they came?

One more example, as this ties into another quote from Milo: "... just like you can get a better car if you pay more." Again, this is Milo making the dumb statement that ISPs wouldn't be allowed to sell tiered packages (i.e., basic [15/1], silver [25/5], gold [50/10], platinum [100/25]). What this statement implies is that if you pay more money, you will get better access. The thing is, with cars, you don't get special treatment on roadways. This is because roads are publicly owned. Railways, telephone lines, and utilities are considered common carriers, entities so central and valuable to our lives that to charge different rates for different parties on arbitrary grounds is deemed immoral.

Back to the car thing, though: whether you buy a Honda Accord or an Audi A4 you do not get special rules based on the maker of your car. Owning a Lexus doesn't mean the freeway speed is 75 MPH while Ford owners are limited to 60 MPH. Is this clear yet?

* Here's an example of what the internet world will look like without net neutrality. Let's say there is a business in Vancouver, Washington, Go To Gutter Guys, a gutter installation and cleaning company. It's a small business which has purchased web hosting from another small business in the Pacific Northwest. Both Go To Gutter Guys and the hosting service use Comcast Xfinity as their ISP. Now, say there is someone in Florida who is trying to help his elderly grandparents in Vancouver find someone to clear their gutters. The person in Florida attempts to connect to gotogutterguys.com to inquire about rates. Our fictional Florida Man does not have Comcast. His ISP instead doesn't have a deal or an arrangement with Comcast or the web hosting service. The Florida Man's ISP then aggressively throttles or even blocks access to the gotoguttersguys.com. Why? Because without net neutrality, there is no consumer protections in place which will prevent any ISP which is not providing the internet service to a party from throttling or blocking access to that party's site. This harms small businesses, medium businesses, civic governments, and consumers far more than federal infrastructure or major companies. Again, all of this is done despite what tiered level of service a party my have purchased.

With net neutrality, you buy service based on your needs. You get a certain maximum download and upload speed. These speeds are slightly mediated by what the content hosting services are paying for. All packets are equal. A world without net neutrality would mean that each contract would require customers to negotiate for not only what level of service they want, but for what access to each site, as effected by what each site has negotiated for it's access to consumers. It is utterly, wholly ridiculous to argue that net neutrality is inherently anti-free speech when its expressed purpose is to prevent companies and governments from determining the value of each packet based on its content and source.

Sorry glorious Milo, but you're just wrong on net neutrality.

This has been an unedited rant. @nrokchi

* This paragraph was added after the original publication to help further clarify and illustrate the harm caused by a lack of consumer protection.

Monday, October 26, 2015

Post 55 -- "That's problematic."

Some morning thoughts came to me while I was preparing a strong brew of coffee. Only black; always strong.

The word "problematic" has always humoured me. It reminds me of the Rocko's Modern Life, where our wallaby star lived in O-Town and everything was something-o-matic. I guess the social justice sorts in this world found things problem-o-matic. Now, if you ask Google, 'what does matic mean?' you get this wonderful result:
""Automatic" can be broken down into auto-, meaning self, and -matic, willing. It therefore translates to "willing to self-perform"."
"Willing", eh? A willing problem? Of course, going back to the dictionary to dig up root meanings of words or particular suffixes or prefixes is pedantic, but this was my original line of reasoning behind why the word 'problematic' makes me laugh so much. Issues to the regressive left are simply automatically a problem, or said another way, are inherently a problem simply for existing, as subjectively evaluated by that given person or ideology.

Skype, the most ubiquitous of online call services, came into being from two Estonian programmers. The service includes a simple echo test for the user's speakers and microphone. The echo test uses a woman's voice. The woman's voice has British accent--I believe a Geordie accent to be specific. Here is how the regressive left deals with something a benign as this. The following is satire and shouldn't be taken seriously.

The Skype echo test voice is problematic as it uses a female voice to depict women as a secretary at the whims of a call service uses.

It is doubly problematic as it fetishizes the accented voice as being more desirable than the user's local accents while also keeping the woman in a submissive support role.

Echo test is triply problematic because it prevents the woman from being able to assist the user, perpetuating the stereotype of women being incompetent with technology, disposable to men's needs as a mere testing agent, and stripped of agency!

It might seem like a caricature of the modern progressive movement, but a moment of reflection on a few recent topics demonstrates the eerie accuracy of this satire. Take, for a quick example, the protests against the Silent Sam statue on UNC-Chapel Hill's campus, the protest against Thomas Jefferson's statue on the Missouri University campus in Columbia, MO, and the feminist protest/activism at the opening of Suffragette, a movie about women's empowerment.

No, this satire is pointed and accurate. That is what makes it satire. Every time I hear something is "problematic", I immediately think of the half dozen spin off issues from the original one, and then play a game of mental bingo to see how far the regressives take it.

This has been an unedited rant. @nrokchi

Thursday, October 8, 2015

Post 54 -- Label 'em, brand 'em

Cattle ranchers, after realizing their bovine were being removed from their care, decided on a rather simple method ensuring their walking steaks would not be easy to steal by branding them. This practice ensured the ranchers' remained honest with each other and made it too difficult for cattle rustlers to sell the animal in local markets.

History has examples of humans being branded for a various reasons, with ownership and punishment being the leading two reasons. A branding label of "B" was used to denote a blasphemer in 17th Century Puritan North America, for example. This terrible human being was not to be trusted and became a pariah--in all communities which he traveled to.

In the internet age, people enjoy labeling others either out of convenience or out of intellectual laziness. This is the point I am going to write to here, illustrating the tricks and paths taken to quickly dismiss or claim others by the most vapid "enlightened" groups of people. It is cultish behaviour to seek out people and label them to be your own as much as it is to proclaim others as heretics.

Go onto YouTube and look up "what is a feminist?" and you'll get a standard block of videos of (mostly) young (mostly) girls reading a dictionary definition of feminism into a webcam. It is the same approach that others, while recruiting, use to get others to "realize" they are a feminists. Do you believe in equality between the sexes? Do you think that women should be paid the same for the same work? Do you believe that woman should have equal access to university and the workplace? If you said 'yes', then you're a feminist! The thing is, I'm not.

Then you're a misogynist!

That is the game in action. Despite saying 'yes' to those questions, I am not a feminist. There are many other tenants which are not listed above that I do not agree with which actively keep me away from the modern feminist movement. The pay gap falsity, the 1-in-4 lie, and Marxist "lack of representation in politics" narratives all keep me away from drinking that particular flavour of Kool-Aide. Not to mention accepting modern feminism is also accepting there is an invisible, unyielding, and unbeatable (but don't tell the zealots) force controlling everything called The Patriarchy.

Using simple data points, which are not comprehensive the entire picture, as anchor points for slapping a label onto someone is lazy and is most certainly disingenuous. Even when attempting to bring in a newest adherent, it is sinister to simplify a movement down to such ambiguous, self-evident facts. Take another example, this time stripped of intent: I own a gun. Now, what does that say about me?

The answer that I own a gun. Nothing more. I could be a pacifist who views it as art. I could be a paranoid man believing aliens will get me and that the gun will protect me from interstellar travelers. I might be a hunter. Or a game warden. Or just a sport shooter. Whether or not I own a gun is only a single fact, unable to be extrapolated into a larger theory. Just as a single datum or case-study does not make a new theory of everything. Facts, however, can be placed under ideological light.

When speaking to a Republican, I'm just an American. (I'm not. I'm a Canadian living in the United States).
When evaluated by progressives, I'm a threat who doesn't care about the lives lost to gun violence.
If asked by my mother, I get a long, "Why?"

Of course, there is some good and some bad from this. The NRA would love to have me as a member based on that single fact. Some gun-control activists want me to register in a mental institution. There is no benefit to being labeled a good person or a bad person based on factoid of me owning a gun. Yet, there are many out there who would be ready to label me something based on it, despite it being entirely neutral.

The quip above about saying that I'm not a feminist leading immediately to being called a misogynist is a general view on how the process works. Again, if I agree that the penis of a baby boy should not be cut because some women find it more appealing when he is older, that does not make me a men's rights activist. Nor does saying that I am not an MRA make me a de facto feminist. The labels are thrown around to either be claimed as part of a movement to bolster numbers and drum up support or they are being rashly applied to the neophytes exploring their understanding of the world know not to encounter the blasphemer. 

This has been an unedited rant. @nrokchi

Friday, September 18, 2015

Post 53 -- Morning musings

The topic of liberty is not one easily understood. It took a complex, winding path to being the basis for a society. Along the way, the were many tangible examples of how throwing off authoritarian pressures allowed for personal and cultural growth, enabling many to pursue happiness. We have not yet arrived at true liberty, but we are close enough to have thrown off the vast majority of false on-high precepts placed upon us.

Alas, and akin to the title of this blog, the blade was not tempered correctly and has warped. Liberty is ordered chaos. The belief that every individual has a duty to himself and to his community; to pursue what is best while not bringing harm to the world around him. The chaos comes from allowing individuals to act in an individualistic way, finding their own path, and dictating their own priorities. The order demanded from liberty is that a disciplined approach to pursue life in an individualistic way does not prevent others from doing the same. This small societal law ensures we can each seek to better ourselves and our place without depriving others of the same opportunity; liberty does not, however, dictate that we must all take the same path.

Surely reading this makes it clear that my description of liberty here are not very well represented in our culture at large. I did start off the previous paragraph with a note of how we seem to have wandered away from the principles of liberty. The individualistic drive is innate in all of us, but to survive as a culture or a community, it must be mindful, disciplined, and aware. Conversely, taking the individualistic drive and divorcing it from sensibility, and one is left with anarchy. Unchecked hyper-individualism is unconcerned about consequences to others by way of one's own actions.

In short, liberty is ordered chaos. Anarchy is chaos ordered. There is a call within anarchy to not just be focused wholly on the self, but to do so in a manner that is callous towards the outcomes for others. Ironic in that anarchy is supposed to operate without order, but the philosophy of anarchy orders its adherents act in a manner that is devoid of order.

Marrying these lukewarm coffee thoughts with what has been a personal motto of mine (we are two steps out of the jungle, not from utopia), I have come to the conclusion that liberty--as it should--has allowed for a perversion of itself to operate. It is not just that we have the freedom granted to us by liberty, but that there are some of us who have thrown liberty to the side in the name of individualistic principles. The loss of structure, either through out-dated punitive measures brought about by authoritarian rule or by the well disciplined mind, has created pockets of moral failings and cultural anarchy on one end and the return of authoritarian lust on the other.

Liberty now lives in the gray area of having failed us but not. Moral education and awareness fosters liberty; promising freedom without morality ensures chaos. In the name of liberty, it should be a greater focus of society at large to educate young people in morality and the meaning of liberty (I may appear to be enacting my own law on myself, but hold off on that for a moment). There is no dogmatism here, however, unless we view liberty, perhaps the highest of human philosophical achievements, as being a dogmatically held belief. By teaching the virtues of self-discipline and the spectrum of human morality, we can hope to develop a world where we have tougher minds and softer hearts.

There is much more to be said about this, and I am sure I will continue to write on the matters of liberty, freedom of speech, and of the failures of understanding those principles by society (and the damage that it causes). For now, though, I am out of coffee.

This has been an unedited rant. @nrokchi

Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Post 52 -- Why write?

What seems to be an all too often occurrence is the emphasis on presentation over substance. A point of fact or rhetorical musing can only be good if presented well. It seems to me a failing of our education and systems which encourage personal growth, develop empathy, and foster an inquisitive mind.

Take TED Talks for example: given the same speaker with the same education and the same break throughs and put him or her on a street corner, would people listen as intently and applaud on cue? I am reminded of a 60 Minutes special looking at the immense strides in neurological oncology at Duke University, where physicians and researchers have been using the Poliovirus to infect and kill glioblastoma, a brutal malignant cancer in the brain that knows no age, race, or gender restrictions. In the report (at 5:25), Scott Pelly states: "As it turns out, when you're one of the world's leading cancer doctors, you can wear what you like." Pelly is referring directly to the Deputy Director of the Poliovirus Clinical Trials Dr. A. Henry Friedman. For those not interested in watching, Dr. Friedman was dressed in a Duke sweatshirt, jeans, and runners. The perception of an accomplished doctor leading a bleeding edge medical trial dressed as a Sunday Ticket bum had to be squared with a quip by the report to assure people of Dr. Friedman's credentials. In other words, Dr. Friedman's presentation was not, in of itself, good enough to make his point.

Now, most people reading this will look at what I've just written and say, 'That's preposterous!' But consider my original reference to TED Talks: would you listen to a person like that if they were in a less organized venue and dressed casually? Simply put, the answer is no.

This bothers me. Not enough to change the whole world, but enough to sit down and put some words to it. Poorly structured on some no-name blogging site which is mostly frequented by bots and my parents. My presentation is poor and boring and does not even have much support outside of my linking it on my Twitter feed on occasion. (Okay, after every post, at least once.) Does that mean the points I make here are worthless or too weak to be considered? I'd like to think not. Not because of some small self-assured part of me, but because of the process by which I come to my conclusions.

The title for this particular post is something of an insight into the slow process of writing for me. There are large gaps in my post frequency. There are rants and there are posts where I read them over slowly to be sure to eliminate as many errors, logical inconsistencies, and unnecessary tangents as I can. I write because I want to write well. I won't write well without going through a long process of writing poorly. Editing. Reading better writers than myself. Writing more. Reading more. And so forth.

I write because I have ideas that I want to put down in some venue that someone might glean some information from. By no means am I an authority on some matters, but that does not mean all points made here are moot. The act of writing improves my future writing. Writing with purpose now will eventually lead to something resembling good writing in the future. I have the topics which I enjoy most: ethics, morality, anti-theism, contrarian approaches to some matters, and the occasional personal insight. I can grow from there, pruning out items that are no longer interesting or pressing to me.

It is a bit of a path to being enlightened. Talking to yourself gives no feedback. Posting something online doesn't really, either, with the immense amount of noise, but at least it has the potential. It refines ideas slowly by forcing me to read what my thoughts are. I can conclude whether or not the drive home rant was something of value or just me passing time. Being a good writer will take time. It will pay off, though: good writers are often better able to present their ideas more succinctly and with better flow. Their good points are obviously good, not requiring them to be verbose or their audience equipped with a thesaurus. I can be better at this and I strive to do so. Being a polemic on the way is also enjoyable.

This has been an unedited rant. @nrokchi